Shopping in "Heart of the Finger Lakes"

Specialty shops and stores with one-of-a-kind gifts
can be found in our many villages and towns. The stores carry gifts and produce that are typical of the region – from buckwheat pancake mix and homemade honey to handmade quilts, jewelry and furniture.

Our wineries offer everything grape, including unique and colorful dishes, soaps, healthy grape seed oils and wine, of course.

Browsing the shops and art galleries along our main streets is a favorite past-time for guests and locals alike, and there are plenty of pubs and restaurants for those much-needed rest stops. Farmer’s markets and road-side stands sell fresh fruits and vegetables, and if you’d like to pick your own fruit, it’s a great way to enjoy the outdoors.

If you need a boat, canoe, kayak or bike, our marinas and rental shops will be pleased to assist you. We pride ourselves on the quality of our small town hospitality, so feel free to drop into the local barber shop or spa to relax and make some new friends. 

We also have a wide range of services available to visitors, including places to rent boats, buy a lakefront home, and surprise loved ones with flowers on that special occasion.

Food and Farm Markets Services

Specialty Stores, Antiques, Retail and Online Shops, and Art Galleries

Birkett Mills

163 Main Street, Penn Yan
Birkett Mills
Country Quest
2358 Bellona Station Road, Penn Yan
Crooked Lake Mercantile
3736 State Route 54A, Branchport
Dahlia's Curios
118 Elm Street, Penn Yan, NY 14527
A delightful collection of Junktiques, Antiques, Vintage Clothing, plus a variety of useful odds and ends. With prices that will make you want to keep coming back. Open May through October 10:00 - 4:00.
Clothes Outs
110 Elm Street, Downtolwn Penn Yan
Affordably priced clothing and accessories for work or play. Casual Wear, Hi-Vis Safety, Military-Spec & Surplus apparel.
Eaton's Plaza Jewelers
232 Lake Street, Penn Yan
Flying Colors
112 Main St., Penn Yan
Specializing in custom embroidery, garment printing and gifts from throughout the Finger Lakes. Located on Main Street in Penn Yan and at the Windmill Farm and Craft Market.
Edgewood Country Store
1427 Voak Road, Penn Yan
Judy's Flower Cart
Charming, all occasion flower and gift shop located in downtown Penn Yan. Fresh and dried flower arrangements, and live dish gardens. Country and primitive gift shop.
J & S Liquor Store
112 West Lake Rd., Penn Yan
Keuka Inspirations
2954 State Rt. 54A, Penn Yan

Keukaview Photography
2799 Knapp Road, Dundee
Finger Lakes photography: landscapes, waterfalls, vineyards and grapes, pet portraits. Beautiful canvas panoramics. Check out our website to view all of our images and find out where you can see our photography at our Home, Local Galleries and Art Shows. Spectacular Finger Lakes Photography


Keuka Lake F rom Knapp Road

Keuka Lake from Knapp Road

Longs' Cards & Books
115 Main Street, Penn Yan
NY Times bestsellers 20% off everyday. Local Hallmark dealer. Office supplies, cards, gifts, candles, frames, souvenirs, and much more! Join our frequent customer punch card.
Lown's House of Shoppes
131 Main Street, Penn Yan
3 floors of Handcrafted Wood Acceessories, Dried Flower Arrangements, Candles, Antiques, Porcelean Dolls, a Christmas Shoppe and Countless Gift Items for everyone.
Lown's House of Shops
Loomis Barn
4940 Loomis Road, Rushville
Mac's Dairy Bar & Mini Golf
2605 Route 14A, Penn Yan
Dairy Bar and Mini Golf
Soft Serve Ice Cream, Hand Dipped Hershey's Ice Cream
Peebles Department Store
254 Lake Street, Penn Yan
The Quilt Room
1860 Hoyt Road, Penn Yan
Scents and Non Scents Shoppe
401 Clinton St., Penn Yan
Unique gifts and candles (made on site) consisting of jars, votives, tarts, aroma beads, incense sticks, scented oils, electric and tea lite warmers. Parties and special orders
The Book's Landing
Main Street, Penn Yan
Used book store open Wednesday - Saturday from 10:00 AM - 4:00 PM.
The Nest Egg
125 Main Street, Penn Yan
Great selection of Vera Bradley, jewelry, signs, Switch Flops. Open 7 days a week.

The Side Door, Antiques and Collectibles
2233 Baker Road, Penn Yan
A general line of furniture, smalls, and primitives in over 1,500 square feet of memories. Please call ahead for after hours appointments.
Torrey Grove Gardens
1570 Rt. 54, Penn Yan
We grow daylilies, iris and hostas, also cut flowers. Open June to August. We will ship plants to most states.

Windmill Farm & Craft Market
Rt. 14A, South of Penn Yan
The Windmill is the first and friendliest farm and craft market in upstate New York, located right in the heart of the Finger Lakes Wine Region.  Midway between Penn Yan and Dundee on NY Route 14A, The Windmill has become a premier tourist attraction, with weekly attendance exceeding 8,000 - 10,000 people. Now in its 22nd year, The Windmill plays host to nearly 200 shops and craftsmen, boasting everything from farm fresh produce to an on-site Chiropractor, you're sure to find something for everyone. A Unique "Heart of the Finger Lakes" Shopping Experience

Food Markets, Farm Markets, Specialty Foods and Grocery Stores

Apple Barrel

2673 San Hill Road, Penn Yan
Chubb’s Farm Market
Hillcrest Bulk and Natural Foods
2901 Route 364, Penn Yan
Keuka Lake Coffee Roasters
Locally roasted, artisanal coffees, award winning coffee-based specialty foods. Unique and delicious! Look for us throughout the Finger Lakes. Experience "JAVALICIOUS".
See our appearance on PBS in Syracuse.
Morgan's Grocery
100 Hamilton Street, Penn Yan
Oak Hill Bulk Foods
3173 State Rt. 14A, Penn Yan

The Olney Place
Market and Deli
823 East Lake Road, Penn Yan
Take Out - Dine In - Catering
Open Daily at 7:00 am.

9 Miles South of Penn Yan on Rt. 54. We are committed to maximizing your time on Keuka Lake. Milk, Chips, Beer, Ice, Soda, Coffee, Sunscreen, Lotto, Hand Dipped Ice Cream, Cigarettes, Charcoal, Cold Cuts,Deli Salads, Eggs, Newspapers, Dockside Gas, Butter, FREE WIFI, Sunglasses, Bait, ATM, Keuka Lake Gift Ideas including Photography by Keukaview, Firewood.

GPS: N 42.548, W 77.096. Earth.
All Major Credit Cards Accepted.

The Olney Place


Spring Wagon Orchards
2732 Wager Hill Road, Penn Yan
Tomion's Farm Market
200 Route 14A, Penn Yan
Wagers Cider Mill
256 East Main St., Penn Yan
Weaver View Farms
1190 Earls Hill Road, Penn Yan
Branchport Hardware
3421 State Route 54, Branchport
315- 546-6622
Carey's Lumber & Rental Outlet
143 Seneca Street, Penn Yan
Elm Street Barber Shop
104 Elm Street, Penn Yan, NY 14527
Finger Lakes Premier Properties
Specializing in the sale of lakefront vacation homes on Keuka, Seneca and Canandaigua Lakes. Whether it's a cozy cabin or a luxury vacation home, our agents can assist. Our agents are certified by the National Association of Realtors as Resort and Second Homes Specialists. Finger Lakes Waterfront Real Estate
Judy’s Flower Cart
134 Main Street, Penn Yan
K&L Cleaners
100 West Lake Rd., Penn Yan

Knapp & Schlappi Lumber Co.
273 Lake Street, Penn Yan
(315) 536-3383
71 Bigelow Ave., Dundee
(607) 243-8900

In the heart of the Finger Lakes Knapp & Schlappi Lumber Co. is your ‘Go To’ place for all of your building and hardware needs

Kn app & Schlappi Lumber Co.

Building Local? Buy Local.

Mark Malcolm II
Broker Associate
Century 21 Sbarra and Wells
MARK MALCOLM II - "Keuka's Top Real Estate Agent", and the #12 agent in the USA, based upon "closed production" in 2009 for the entire Century 21 System (with over 120,000 agents)!
Penn Yan Electronics (Radio Shack)
228 Lake Street, Penn Yan

Pinckney Hardware
24 Main Street, Penn Yan
Polmanteer Auto Service Center
Trombley Tire & Auto
143 East Elm St., Penn Yan
REMAX Diversified Rentals
Dan Morse - Associate Broker
315-536-7446 ext. 111 or 315-719-7372
Top producing agent, area native familar with residential, vacation, lake, land, and farm properties. Ready to assist you with all your buying and selling needs.


Marina’s and Boat Supplies
Morgan Marine
2 Route 54, Penn Yan